On Thursday, idolreview.net predicts SHANNON MAGRANE will go home.
Here is the official archive of my American Idol finalist prediction lists. You can see how “accurate” (read: crappy) my predictions have been. (Spoiler Alert: they have gotten progressively worse over time.)
Season 10
| My predictions | How it really went down |
| 13. Ashthon Jones | 13. Ashthon Jones |
| 12. Naima Adedapo | 12. Karen Rodriguez |
| 11. Haley Reinhart | 11. (Judges Save Used) |
| 10. Paul McDonald | 10. Naima Adedapo/Thia Megia |
| 09. Karen Rodriguez | 09. Pia Toscano |
| 08. Thia Megia | 08. Paul McDonald |
| 07. Stefano Langone | 07. Stefano Langone |
| 06. Lauren Alaina | 06. Casey Abrams |
| 05. Jacob Lusk | 05. Jacob Lusk |
| 04. Scotty McCreery | 04. James Durbin |
| 03. Casey Abrams | 03. Haley Reinhart |
| 02. James Durbin | 02. Lauren Alaina |
| 01. Pia Toscano | 01. Scotty McCreery |
Season 9
*coming soon*
Season 8
| My predictions | How it really went down |
| 13. Michael Sarver | 13. Jasmine Murray |
| 12. Megan Corkrey | 12. Jorge Nuñez |
| 11. Kris Allen | 11. Alexis Grace |
| 10. Jasmine Murray | 10. Michael Sarver |
| 09. Jorge Nuñez | 09. Megan Corkrey |
| 08. Scott McIntyre | 08. Scott McIntyre |
| 07. Anoop Desai | 07. Lil Rounds |
| 06. Adam Lambert | 06. Anoop Desai |
| 05. Allison Iraheta | 05. Matt Giraud |
| 04. Lil Rounds | 04. Allison Iraheta |
| 03. Danny Gokey | 03. Danny Gokey |
| 02. Alexis Grace | 02. Adam Lambert |
| 01. Matt Giraud | 01. Kris Allen |
Season 7
| My predictions | How it really went down |
| 12. David Hernandez | 12. David Hernandez |
| 11. Chikezie Eze | 11. Amanda Overmyer |
| 10. Amanda Overmyer | 10. Chikezie Eze |
| 09. Ramiele Malubay | 09. Ramiele Malubay |
| 08. Kristy Lee Cook | 08. Michael Johns |
| 07. Jason Castro | 07. Kristy Lee Cook |
| 06. Carly Smithson | 06. Carly Smithson |
| 05. Brooke White | 05. Brooke White |
| 04. David Cook | 04. Jason Castro |
| 03. Syesha Mercado | 03. Syesha Mercado |
| 02. Michael Johns | 02. David Archuleta |
| 01. David Archuleta | 01. David Cook |
Season 6
| My predictions | How it really went down |
| 12. Haley Scarnato | 12. Brandon Rogers |
| 11. Sanjaya Malakar | 11. Stephanie Edwards |
| 10. Brandon Rogers | 10. Chris Sligh |
| 09. Phil Stacey | 09. Gina Glocksen |
| 08. Stephanie Edwards | 08. Haley Scarnato |
| 07. Chris Sligh | 07. Sanjaya Malakar |
| 06. Jordin Sparks | 06/05. Phil Stacey |
| 05. Gina Glocksen | 06/05. Chris Richardson |
| 04. LaKisha Jones | 04. LaKisha Jones |
| 03. Chris Richardson | 03. Melinda Doolittle |
| 02. Blake Lewis | 02. Blake Lewis |
| 01. Melinda Doolittle | 01. Jordin Sparks |
Season 5
| My predictions | How it really went down |
| 12. Bucky Covington | 12. Melissa McGhee |
| 11. Kevin Covais | 11. Kevin Covais |
| 10. Melissa McGhee | 10. Lisa Tucker |
| 09. Lisa Tucker | 09. Mandisa |
| 08. Kellie Pickler | 08. Bucky Covington |
| 07. Elliott Yamin | 07. Ace Young |
| 06. Paris Bennett | 06. Kellie Pickler |
| 05. Ace Young | 05. Paris Bennett |
| 04. Taylor Hicks | 04. Chris Daughtry |
| 03. Mandisa | 03. Elliott Yamin |
| 02. Katharine McPhee | 02. Katharine McPhee |
| 01. Chris Daughtry | 01. Taylor Hicks |
Season 4
| My predictions | How it really went down |
| 12. Lindsey Cardinale | 12. Lindsey Cardinale |
| 11. Mikalah Gordon | 11. Mikalah Gordon |
| 10. Nikko Smith | 10. Jessica Sierra |
| 09. Constantine Maroulis | 09. Nikko Smith |
| 08. Nadia Turner | 08. Nadia Turner |
| 07. Scott Savol | 07. Anwar Robinson |
| 06. Anthony Federov | 06. Constantine Maroulis |
| 05. Jessica Sierra | 05. Scott Savol |
| 04. Vonzell Solomon | 04. Anthony Federov |
| 03. Bo Bice | 03. Vonzell Solomon |
| 02. Anwar Robinson | 02. Bo Bice |
| 01. Carrie Underwood | 01. Carrie Underwood |
